Stuffed Cookie Collection

17 Stuffed Christmas Cookies with Surprise Centers

17 Stuffed Christmas Cookies with Surprise Centers - A curated collection of Christmas cookie recipes from The Cookie Index.

🍪 17 RecipesRecipe collection🎄 Christmas
1Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Cookies: cut peanut butter cup cookies showing a chocolate and peanut butter center.Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Cookies

Peanut Butter Cup Stuffed Cookies: cookies with a sealed chocolate peanut butter cup inside, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 54 minGet Recipe→
2Biscoff-stuffed gingerbread cookies with a smooth spiced cookie-butter center visible inside a chewy molasses shell.Gingerbread

Biscoff-Stuffed Gingerbread Cookies

Biscoff-stuffed gingerbread cookies with a smooth spiced cookie-butter center visible inside a chewy molasses shell.

⏱️ 57 minGet Recipe→
3Rolo Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies: cut peanut butter cookies showing a caramel-filled chocolate center.Peanut Butter

Rolo Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies

Rolo Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies: peanut butter cookies enclosing a soft center, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 49 minGet Recipe→
4Rice-flour yolk shortbread sealed around small pieces of soft caramel.Shortbread

Salted Caramel Stuffed Shortbread Cookies

Rice-flour yolk shortbread sealed around small pieces of soft caramel.

⏱️ 83 minGet Recipe→
5Shortbread dough cups hold a small spoonful of thick fruit mincemeat, baked until the pastry edges turn golden and the center is set.Shortbread

Mincemeat-Filled Shortbread Cup Cookies

Shortbread dough cups hold a small spoonful of thick fruit mincemeat, baked until the pastry edges turn golden and the center is set.

⏱️ 47 minGet Recipe→
6Large caramel-stuffed gingerbread cookies with a sugar crust and an enclosed chewy caramel center.Gingerbread

Caramel-Stuffed Gingerbread Cookies

Large caramel-stuffed gingerbread cookies with a sugar crust and an enclosed chewy caramel center.

⏱️ 57 minGet Recipe→
7Sealed square shortcrust pockets with a dense dried-fig and almond filling, an Italian-style home adaptation.Italian

Fig Almond Filled Cookies

Sealed square shortcrust pockets with a dense dried-fig and almond filling, an Italian-style home adaptation.

⏱️ 105 minGet Recipe→
8Chewy sugar cookies with a soft caramel center and a cinnamon-sugar top.Sugar Cookies

Caramel-Stuffed Sugar Cookies

Chewy sugar cookies with a soft caramel center and a cinnamon-sugar top.

⏱️ 64 minGet Recipe→
9Egg-yolk shortbread rolls enclosing a thick fig paste with finely chopped walnuts.Shortbread

Fig Walnut Filled Shortbread Rolls

Egg-yolk shortbread rolls enclosing a thick fig paste with finely chopped walnuts.

⏱️ 84 minGet Recipe→
10Reese’s Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies: cut peanut butter cookies revealing chocolate peanut butter cups enclosed inside.Peanut Butter

Reese’s Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies

Reese’s Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies: cookies with a sealed chocolate peanut butter cup inside, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 54 minGet Recipe→
11Nutella Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies: cut peanut butter cookies showing a soft chocolate hazelnut spread center.Peanut Butter

Nutella Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies

Nutella Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies: peanut butter cookies enclosing a soft center, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 49 minGet Recipe→
12Nutella-stuffed gingerbread cookies with a glossy chocolate-hazelnut center fully enclosed inside one chewy spiced cookie.Gingerbread

Nutella-Stuffed Gingerbread Cookies

Nutella-stuffed gingerbread cookies with a glossy chocolate-hazelnut center fully enclosed inside one chewy spiced cookie.

⏱️ 57 minGet Recipe→
13A batch of jam-filled spritz cookies arranged on a ceramic plate.Spritz

Jam-Filled Spritz Cookies

Jam-Filled Spritz Cookies: buttery Christmas spritz cookies with title-specific flavor, shaping and finishing details.

⏱️ 52 minGet Recipe→
14Gingerbread cookie cups with sturdy baked walls and a generous piped swirl of no-bake cinnamon cheesecake filling.Gingerbread

Cheesecake-Filled Gingerbread Cookie Cups

Gingerbread cookie cups with sturdy baked walls and a generous piped swirl of no-bake cinnamon cheesecake filling.

⏱️ 55 minGet Recipe→
15Marshmallow Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies: peanut butter cookies broken open to show a white marshmallow center.Peanut Butter

Marshmallow Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies

Marshmallow Stuffed Peanut Butter Cookies: peanut butter cookies enclosing a soft center, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 49 minGet Recipe→
16A batch of chocolate-filled spritz sandwich cookies arranged on a ceramic plate.Spritz

Chocolate-Filled Spritz Sandwich Cookies

Chocolate-Filled Spritz Sandwich Cookies: buttery Christmas spritz cookies with title-specific flavor, shaping and finishing details.

⏱️ 52 minGet Recipe→
17Soft vanilla sugar cookies with a cinnamon cookie-butter pocket inside.Sugar Cookies

Biscoff-Stuffed Sugar Cookies

Soft vanilla sugar cookies with a cinnamon cookie-butter pocket inside.

⏱️ 59 minGet Recipe→