Cookie Tin Collection

17 Cookie Recipes to Fill Your Christmas Cookie Tins

17 Cookie Recipes to Fill Your Christmas Cookie Tins - A curated collection of Christmas cookie recipes from The Cookie Index.

🍪 17 RecipesRecipe collection🎄 Christmas
1Classic vanilla sugar cookies with lightly crisp golden edges and a tender buttery center.Sugar Cookies

Classic Sugar Cookies

Classic vanilla sugar cookies with lightly crisp golden edges and a tender buttery center.

⏱️ 68 minGet Recipe→
2A batch of blackberry spritz cookies arranged on a ceramic plate.Spritz

Blackberry Spritz Cookies

Blackberry Spritz Cookies: buttery Christmas spritz cookies with title-specific flavor, shaping and finishing details.

⏱️ 52 minGet Recipe→
3Gingerbread thumbprints filled with smooth amber apple butter, pairing a molasses cookie with concentrated apple-cinnamon flavor.Gingerbread

Apple Butter Gingerbread Cookies

Gingerbread thumbprints filled with smooth amber apple butter, pairing a molasses cookie with concentrated apple-cinnamon flavor.

⏱️ 70 minGet Recipe→
4Christmas Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies: golden peanut butter cookies with chocolate peanut butter cup centers.Peanut Butter

Christmas Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies

Christmas Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookies: mini peanut butter cookie cups with a chocolate peanut butter center, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 54 minGet Recipe→
5Large bakery-style gingerbread cut-outs with thick centers, neat outlines and a generous decorating surface.Gingerbread

Bakery-Style Gingerbread Cookies

Large bakery-style gingerbread cut-outs with thick centers, neat outlines and a generous decorating surface.

⏱️ 77 minGet Recipe→
6Christmas Peanut Butter Blossoms: golden round cookies with chocolate kiss-shaped centers on a ceramic plate.Peanut Butter

Christmas Peanut Butter Blossoms

Christmas Peanut Butter Blossoms: sugar-rolled peanut butter cookies with a chocolate center, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 49 minGet Recipe→
7Golden-brown star-shaped sugar cookies with dark brown sugar, subtle warm spices and clean cut-out edges.Sugar Cookies

Brown Sugar Cut-Out Sugar Cookies

Golden-brown star-shaped sugar cookies with dark brown sugar, subtle warm spices and clean cut-out edges.

⏱️ 71 minGet Recipe→
8Parbaked shortbread beneath a crisp walnut-studded maple meringue cap.Shortbread

Maple Walnut Meringue Shortbread Squares

Parbaked shortbread beneath a crisp walnut-studded maple meringue cap.

⏱️ 100 minGet Recipe→
9Italian-style pistachio butter cookies with orange zest and shallow wells of glossy orange marmalade.Italian

Orange Pistachio Thumbprints

Italian-style pistachio butter cookies with orange zest and shallow wells of glossy orange marmalade.

⏱️ 72 minGet Recipe→
10A batch of blue christmas spritz cookies arranged on a ceramic plate.Spritz

Blue Christmas Spritz Cookies

Blue Christmas Spritz Cookies: buttery Christmas spritz cookies with title-specific flavor, shaping and finishing details.

⏱️ 52 minGet Recipe→
11Buttery gingerbread-spiced madeleines with distinct shell ridges, a tender sponge crumb and a light sugar dusting.Gingerbread

Gingerbread Madeleines

Buttery gingerbread-spiced madeleines with distinct shell ridges, a tender sponge crumb and a light sugar dusting.

⏱️ 54 minGet Recipe→
12Chewy gingerbread cheesecake cookies with a creamy white center fully enclosed in the baked molasses dough.Gingerbread

Gingerbread Cheesecake Cookies

Chewy gingerbread cheesecake cookies with a creamy white center fully enclosed in the baked molasses dough.

⏱️ 68 minGet Recipe→
13A batch of lemon spritz cookies arranged on a ceramic plate.Spritz

Lemon Spritz Cookies

Lemon Spritz Cookies: buttery Christmas spritz cookies with title-specific flavor, shaping and finishing details.

⏱️ 52 minGet Recipe→
14Stabilized peanut butter and a low-sugar dough produce thick, fork-marked shortbread with a dense nutty crumb.Shortbread

Peanut-Butter Christmas Shortbread

Stabilized peanut butter and a low-sugar dough produce thick, fork-marked shortbread with a dense nutty crumb.

⏱️ 64 minGet Recipe→
15No-Bake Peanut Butter Balls: round peanut butter confections with chocolate shells, with a cut center showing the filling.Peanut Butter

No-Bake Peanut Butter Balls

No-Bake Peanut Butter Balls: chilled peanut butter centers under a chocolate coating, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 40 minGet Recipe→
16A batch of classic cookie press cookies arranged on a ceramic plate.Spritz

Classic Cookie Press Cookies

Classic Cookie Press Cookies: buttery Christmas spritz cookies with title-specific flavor, shaping and finishing details.

⏱️ 52 minGet Recipe→
17Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Cookies: golden peanut butter cookies with fork markings and a broken cookie showing the crumb.Peanut Butter

Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Cookies

Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Cookies: peanut butter cookies made with a gluten-free baking blend, with measured ingredients and a complete batch method.

⏱️ 49 minGet Recipe→