Amish Collection

15 Amish Christmas Cookies Simple Traditional

15 Amish Christmas Cookies Simple Traditional - Curated Christmas cookie recipes from The Cookie Index.

🍪 15 RecipesRecipe collection🎄 Christmas

Blueberry Sugar Cookies

Soft violet blueberry sugar cookies with real berry pockets and a sparkling sugar coating.

Soft vanilla sugar cookies with a cinnamon cookie-butter pocket inside.

Soft, pale buttermilk sugar-cookie rounds with a tender cakey crumb and a subtle cultured tang.

Golden-brown star-shaped sugar cookies with dark brown sugar, subtle warm spices and clean cut-out edges.

Tender anise cut-outs with a thin milk glaze and a delicate licorice aroma.

Soft almond sugar cookies with a light almond glaze and optional sliced almonds over gently golden edges.

Golden brown-butter sugar cookies with toasted milk-solid flecks, soft centers and a warm nutty aroma.

Red-and-white twisted peppermint sugar cookies shaped into small candy canes, with a sparkling peppermint finish.

Puffy sour-cream sugar cookies with a soft cake-like crumb and a generous swirl of vanilla buttercream.

Stacked graduated sugar-cookie stars with green icing and a little sugar-cookie star topper.

Soft Amish-style sugar cookies made with butter, oil and two sugars for a fine melt-away crumb.

Naturally charcoal-gray black sesame sugar cookies with a sparkling coating and chewy nutty centers.

Caramel-toned brown sugar cookies with chewy centers, fine crinkled tops and a sparkling sugar coating.

Apple-shaped cider sugar cookies with a warm apple-spice flavor and crisp, tidy cut-out edges.

Gluten-free almond-flour sugar cookies with crackly sugar tops and a soft nutty crumb.